A Study to Assess the Effectiveness of Self Instructional Module (SIM) onKnowledge Regarding Evidence Based Nursing Practice Among Staff Nurses Working in Selected Hospitals at Jaipur
Sunil Kumar *1, Sumit Kumar Poonia 2, Pradeep Kumar Bishnoi 3, Shanti Lal Kumawat4
1.Principal Investigator – Sunil Kumar, Asst. Manager Nursing, TATA Memorial Centre,Homi Bhabha Cancer Hospital, Punjab
2.Co- Investigator - Sumit Kumar Poonia, Nursing Officer, AIIMS, Rishikesh
3.Co- Investigator - Pradeep Kumar Bishnoi, Nurse-A, NAPS (Narora Atomic Power Station) Hospital
4.Co- Investigator - Shanti Lal Kumawat, Nurse-A, TATA Memorial Centre, Homi Bhabha Cancer Hospital, Punjab
*Correspondence to: Sunil Kumar, Principal Investigator, Asst. Manager Nursing, TATA Memorial Centre, Homi Bhabha Cancer Hospital, Punjab
Copyright
© 2023 Sunil Kumar. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Received: 27 November 2023
Published: 13 December 2023
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo. 10532753
Abstract
Health care professionals including doctors, nurses and paramedical staffs are the guardians of the community. It is the duty of the entire health care establishments to ensure speedy recovery of their patients by providing quality health care.
1.To assess the existing knowledge of staff nurses regarding Evidence Based Nursing Practice working in selected hospital.
2.To develop, validate & administer Self Instructional Module.
3.To assess the effectiveness of Self-Instructional Module.
4.To find an association of knowledge with their selected demographic variables like age, gender, experience, professional qualification etc.
Method
An evaluative research approach was adapted in order to assess the knowledge on Evidence Based Nursing Practice among staff nurses in a selected hospital at Jaipur.
A Quasi-experimental design with one group pre-test post-test design was used to evaluate the effectiveness of Self Instructional Module for the present study. The content validity of tool and SIM was established by five experts in the field of nursing. The pilot study was conducted on 35 items for its clarity, unambiguity, feasibility on similar subjects. The main study was carried out on 60 staff nurses at BMCHRC Hospital, Jaipur by non- probability convenient sampling technique. A structured knowledge questionnaire was administered for data collection procedure. The plan of data analysis includes both descriptive and inferential statistics.
The collected data was organized, tabulated and analyzed based on the objectives of the study by using descriptive statistics ie, frequency and percentage, inferential statistics i.e, Chi- square „t? test and correlation coefficient. The paired „t? test was used to find out the difference between pre-test and post-test level of knowledge and the Chi-square was used to find out the association between the demographic variables.
1.The maximum of staff nurses (43.33%) belongs to 31-40 years age group.
2.The majority of staff nurses (58.33%) were male.
3.The maximum of staff nurses (40.00%) had professional education in Post Basic BSc Nursing.
4.The majority of staff nurses (38.33%) were working in surgical ward.
5.The majority of staff nurses (48.33%) professional experience was 16 years & above.
6.The majority of staff nurses (61.66%) had academic source of knowledge.
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
EBP : Evidence Based Practice
EBNP : Evidence Based Nursing Practice
JCAHO: Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organisation
SIM : Self Instructional Module
WHO : World Health Organisation
Df : Degree of freedom
P : Probability
r : Correlation Coefficient
SD : Standard Deviation
CINAHL : Cumulative Index to Nursing & Allied Health Literature. RN Registered Nurses
SMSH : Sawai Man Singh Hospital
“The first step towards knowledge is to know that we are ignorant” Richard Cecil-
The past century has witnessed spectacular changes in the way we live and think. Human brilliance and technology have come together to propose solutions we dared not imagine fifty years ago. Many diseases have been conquered, millions of people have been saved from premature death and disability and the search for better solutions to healthcare is on.[1]
Like most disciplines, nursing consists of both scientific knowledge and conventional wisdom (knowledge that has not been empirically tested). Traditionally only what stands the text of repeated measures constitutes truth or knowledge. Classical scientific process however are net suitable for creating and describing all types of knowledge for the caring profession of nursing.[1]
Social sciences and behavioural sciences and the arts rely on other methods to establish knowledge. There is an ongoing emphasis on development of nursing knowledge through research and theory building to improve their practice base. Nursing relies on multiple ways of knowledge because it has characteristics of social, behavioural and biological science.[1]
“The learning and knowledge that we have, is, at the most, but little compared with that of which we are ignorant.” Plato-
It is believed that theory guided practice is the future of nursing enters into the 21st Century. Theory guided practice must be placed at the core of nursing and must integrate relevant-outcome-driven practice with the art and science of caring and healing.[1]
The concept of EBP in nursing is still in a very primitive stage in many parts of the world. Nursing practice in most parts in India is based on experience, tradition, intuition, common sense and untested theories. Nurses should be encouraged to recognize the theoretical basis for practice and see ways to enhance the knowledge base which supports practice right from the beginning of their working.
Their needs to be an elevated emphasis on increasing reciprocal interaction among theory, research and practice with bridging gap between practices.[1]
Florence Nightingale would probably not recognise the nurse of today. As we move into the next millennium, we expect nurses to care with their hearts and minds; identify patients? actual and potential problems; and develop research-based strategies to prevent, ameliorate, and comfort.[2]
In todays complex and dynamic patient care environment, nursing interventions and process informed by the best evidence are vital to realizing health care improvements and cost savings.[3]
Numbering more than 2 million and practicing in most health-care settings, nurses make up the largest number of health care professionals, Every patient is likely to receive nursing care. Therefore, nurses are in important position to influence the type, quality, and cost of care provided to patients.[3]
Increased emphasis on efficiency, cost containment and quality in a healthcare system that is rapidly changing and advancement of science and technology have lead to the need for reliable, up to date evidence that could improve the healthcare system is accordance with the advancements.[4]
Today, nurses are actively generating, publishing, and applying research in practice to improve client care and enhance nursing?s scientific knowledge base. Recently, there has been increased emphasis on the importance of evidence based practice, that is, the use of some form of substantiation in making clinical decisions. This substantiation, or evidence, can arise from tradition, authority, experience trial and error, logic or reason or research.[4]
Evidence based practice (EBP) has been described as “the integration of best research evidence with clinical expertise and patient values”. There are various models to provide a frame work for moving evidence and research in to practice.[4]
The demand of healthcare increased dramatically all over the world. This presented new opportunities and changes in the nursing profession. A methodology for clinical practice which is emerging across the nursing discipline is termed as “Evidence Based Nursing Practice”. Evidence based nursing integrates the best evidence from research with clinical expertise, patient preference, and existing resources into decision making about the healthcare of individual patients.[5]
Need of the Study
“Unless we are making progress in our nursing every year, every month, Every week, take my word for it we are going back”. Florence Nightingale
The generation of empirical knowledge is essential to improve clinical practice. It has been the major focus of researchers since 1980. The generation and diffusion of empirical knowledge are expanding each and every day. With the current changes in the healthcare system, society is demanding more of nurses? involvement than ever before.[6]
Nurses now have the attention of healthcare policy makers and can influence the future delivery system. Meeting policy makers expectations require carrying out of high quality research and the use of those findings in practice.[6]
During the 1980s, the term “Evidence Based Medicine” emerged to describe the approach that use scientific evidence to determine the best practice. The Evidence based practice takes resources, work, time, and effort, but the outcomes make them worthwhile. Every patient deserves care that is based on the best scientific knowledge and that ensures high quality , cost-effective.[7]
The centres for Medicare & Medicaid services; various organizations that represent hospitals, doctors & employers; accrediting organizations; other federal agencies; and the public have combined efforts to develop Hospital Compare and, thus, made key clinical outcome measures available to the public. In t his way, the public can monitor performance indicators to related common medical conditions and certain evidence based interventions that are consistent with achieving the best patient outcomes.[7]
A recent study provided in 2005 evidence that most nurses provide care in accordance with what they learnt in nursing school and rarely used journal articles, research reports, and hospital libraries for reference. That finding, combined with the fact that the average nurse is more than 40 years of age, makes it apparent that many nurses? knowledge is probably out-dated. Practice based on such knowledge does not translate into quality patient care or health outcomes. Evidence based practice provides a critical strategy to ensure that care is up to date and that it reflects the latest research evidence.[7]
A study conducted in 2003, that the nurses? most helpful knowledge source was experience or advice from colleagues or patients. Of concern, reports that up to date electronic resources that included evidence-based materials were not useful to nurses in clinical practice. This barrier contributes to significant gaps in clinicians applying research findings to practice and dissemination of innovations. The failure to use evidence results in care that is of lower quality, less effective, and more expensive.[7]
In 2002, the Centres for Disease Control & Prevention published Guideline for Hygiene in Health-Care Settings, which provides healthcare workers with a review of data regarding hand-washing and hand antisepsis in healthcare environments. Furthermore, it makes recommendations to improve hand-hygiene practices and reduced transmission of pathogenic micro organisms to both patients and health care personnel.[7]
Evidence-Based Nursing Practice (EBNP) is the wave of the future. Increasingly, Evidence Based Nursing Practice is being identified as a key to quality and excellence in nursing services. Incorporating evidence into practice is necessary to deliver scientifically sound patient care. Despite the growing popularity of evidence based nursing practice and its documented significant benefits, there is only 15% of the nursing work force consistently practices within the evidence based nursing practice frame work. If evidence based nursing practice adoption is to increase in the profession, it will require the active efforts of nurses to increase their knowledge regarding evidence based nursing practice.[8]
Evidence-Based Nursing Practice, or evidence based decision making, is rapidly developing as a growth industry in nursing and the health professions more widely. It has its origins in the work of the British Epidemiologist Archie Cochrane and has recently been re- energized in Canada by the National Forum on Health and its call for culture evidence - based decision making. Before we adopt EBN as a Mantra for the 21st Century, we should examine its origins and its consequences, and we should probe related concepts, two of which are the nature and structure of practice-based knowledge and the nature and structure evidence generally.[9]
A survey that was established by the Sigma Theta Tau International, Honor Society of Nursing (2002) and completed by registered nurses provided that 69% have a low to moderate knowledge regarding Evidence
- Based Practice and half of those that responded did not feel sure of the steps, the process consist of Evidence-Based Nursing Practice leads to higher quality care, improved patient outcomes, reduced costs and greater nurse satisfaction than traditional approaches to care.[10]
Nurses are responsible for the care they provide to their patients. Evidence- based practice in nursing means making decisions about patient care on the basis of current best available evidence. It helps the nurse to provide high-quality care to her patients based on research and knowledge. Evidence - based practice increases the efficiency of nurses. Making decisions based on knowledge that is backed by research makes it easier for a nurse to choose what care to provide to her patient as opposed to trying something that may or may not be beneficial to her patient. This saves her time, which she can devote to patients who need more intensive care from her.[11] Using Evidence-based practice to provide care to patients increases the nurse?s confidence. This is because she knows that she is basing her decisions about patient care on valid information that has been thoroughly researched. For nurses to apply Evidence-based practice in the care they provide, they have to say informed on any new discoveries that have been made. This encourages them to read materials that cover nursing research thus keeping their practice current. [11]
Evidence-based practice has gained momentum in nursing, and definitions vary widely. Research findings, knowledge from basic science, clinical knowledge, and expert opinion are all considered “evidence”, however, practices based on research findings is more likely to result in the desired patient outcomes across various settings and geographic locations. The impetus for Evidence based practice comes from payer and healthcare facility pressure for cost containment, greater availability of information, and greater consumer savvy about treatment and care options. Evidence-based practice demands changes in education of students, more practice-relevant research, and closer working relationships between clinicians and researchers. Evidence-based practice also provides opportunities for nursing care to be more individualized, more effective, streamlined, and dynamic, and to maximize effects of clinical judgment. When evidence is used to define best practices rather than to support existing practices. Nursing care keeps pace with the latest technological advances and takes advantage of new knowledge developments.[12]
The expectation for high quality, cost-effective care and the rapid expansion of easily accessible knowledge in a competing healthcare market place have driven the need for the daily use of evidence to improve point
The primary task of nursing research is to contribute to the scientific base of nursing practice. Science is needed to determine the effectiveness of nursing interventions and nursing care. Through such research efforts, the science of nursing will grow and a scientifically based rational for making changes in nursing practice and patient care will be generated. Evidence-based practice will be facilitated, with a resultant increase in the quality of patient care.[14]
So, the researcher felt that it is necessary to impart knowledge through Self Instructional Module on Evidence Based Nursing Practice among staff nurses for quality care in turn to promotion of total healthcare delivery system.
Statement of the Problem:
“A STUDY TO ASSESS THE EFFECTIVENESS OF SELF INSTRUCTIONAL MODULE (SIM) ON KNOWLEDGE REGARDING EVIDENCE BASED NURSING PRACTICE AMONG STAFF NURSES WORKING IN SELECTED HOSPITALS AT JAIPUR”.
Objectives of the Study:
1.To assess the existing knowledge of staff nurses regarding Evidence Based Nursing Practice working in selected hospital.
2.To develop, validate & administer self instructional module.
3.To assess the effectiveness of self instructional module.
4.To find an association of knowledge with selected demographic variables like age, gender, experience, professional qualification etc.
Operational Definitions
1.ASSESS: It refers to the measurement of knowledge of the nurses working in hospitals regarding Evidence Based Nursing Practice.
2.EFFECTIVENESS: It refers to the gain in the knowledge on Evidence Based Nursing Practice among staff nurses working in selected hospital at Jaipur city.
3.SELF INSTRUCTIONAL MODULE: It is planned and documented information given to staff nurses regarding Evidence Based Nursing Practice.
4.KNOWLEDGE: It refers to the awareness, amount of information or understanding about Evidence Based Nursing Practice among staff nurses as measured by structured questionnaire. Knowledge will be measured in terms of knowledge scores.
5.EVIDENCE BASED NURSING PRACTICE: Evidence Based Nursing Practice means making decisions about patient care on the basis of current best available evidence.
6.STAFF NURSE: Is a person who has successfully completed the General Nursing & Midwifery course or Bachelor of Science in nursing and working in selected hospital at Jaipur city.
7.DEMOGRAPHIC VARIABLES: The demographic variable is an uncontrolled variable that greatly influences the results of the study. The study also consists of demographic variables such as, gender, age, professional qualification, professional experience, area of working, and source of knowledge etc.
Assumptions:
The researcher assumes that:
a.Evidence Based Nursing Practice may improves the quality of patient care.
b.Evidence Based Nursing Practice may improves the nurses confidence to give nursing care.
c.The SIM may enhance the knowledge of staff nurses on Evidence Based Nursing Practice.
Research Hypothesis:
H1: There will be a significant difference between existing and post-test level scores of knowledge regarding Evidence Based Nursing Practice among staff nurses.
H2: There will be a significant association between the level of knowledge and selected demographic variables of staff nurses regarding Evidence Based Nursing Practice.
The research will be confines to nursing staffs;
Who are working in selected hospital.
Who are like to participate in the study.
Variables:
The independent variable:
The independent variable is the condition or characteristics is manipulated by the researcher. In experimental studies, the independent variable is the “cause” or the variable that is thought to influence the independent variable.[15]In this study the independent variable is the Self Instructional Module on Evidence Based Nursing Practice.
The dependent variable:
The dependent variable is the effect or the variable that is influenced by the researcher?s manipulation of the independent variable. It is the effect of the action of independent variable.15
The dependent variable in this study is the knowledge score of the staff nurses.
The demographic variable:
The demographic variable is an uncontrolled variable that greatly influences the results of the study.
The study also consists of demographic variables such as, gender, age, professional qualification, professional experience, area of working, and source of knowledge etc.
Conceptual Framewok
Conceptual framework is inter-related concepts or obstructions that assembled together in some rational scheme by virtue of relevance to a common theme. Conceptual framework helps to stimulate research and the extension of knowledge by providing both direction and inputs.16
The purpose of conceptual is to provide a logical, coherent through which phenomena of concern can be understood and discussed .Conceptual frame wok provides a frame of reference for members of a discipline to guide their thinking; observation and interpretation, propositions of a conceptual framework are abstract and general.
The selected conceptual framework in the present study was based on Context, Input, Process and Product modes by Stuffle Beam (1960). It consists of four steps namely- Context, Input, Process and Product evaluation, in which context refers to goal setting, input refers to information to be processed for the desired outcome, process refers to the method by which the input can be processed and product is released and product refers to the output.
In the present study, Context refers to formulation of objectives and hypotheses to evaluate the effectiveness of self instructional module for staff nurses regarding Evidence Based Nursing Practice.
According to the study, Input includes assessing the knowledge of staff nurses regarding EBNP using pre- test.
Please click here to view complete article